[Costing & Quoting]

Make vs. Buy Calculator

In-house manufacturing cost vs. outsourcing.

Cost Inputs
units
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
Cost Comparison

Total Make Cost

$165,000.00

Total Buy Cost

$195,000.00

Make Cost / Unit

$16.00

Buy Cost / Unit

$19.50

Decision Summary

Break-Even Volume

1,429 units / yr

Annual Savings

$30,000.00

Total Cost
Make In-House$165,000.00
Buy from Supplier$195,000.00

Make in-house. Building these parts yourself costs $30,000.00 less per year (15.4% cheaper than buying).

How Make vs Buy Works

Total Make = (Material + Labor + Overhead) × Volume + Setup

Run one part at one realistic Annual Volume. Overhead Cost / Unit is the trap: enter only overhead that genuinely goes away if you stop making the part, because rent, depreciation and salaried supervision stay on the books whether the part is bought or not, and loading the full absorbed rate quietly hands the decision to the supplier. Labor Cost / Unit counts only if those hours are removed or filled with other work. Setup / Tooling Cost is the one-time spend, entered whole. On the buy side, use a Purchase Price / Unit quoted at this volume, and put incoming inspection and paperwork into Inspection Cost / Unit rather than ignoring them.

Make CostMaterial + Labor + Overheadper unit, plus setup / tooling
Buy CostPurchase + Shipping + Inspectionper unit, no setup
Break-EvenSetup CostBuy/Unit − Make/Unit
Frequently Asked Questions

Why does break-even volume show no usable number?

Because making is already dearer per unit than buying before any tooling is counted. Break-even divides Setup / Tooling Cost by the gap between Buy Cost / Unit and Make Cost / Unit, so the gap has to be positive for a crossover volume to exist. If it is negative, no volume rescues the make case.

Which overhead belongs in the make cost per unit?

Only the avoidable part. The calculator treats Overhead Cost / Unit as cost that disappears with the work, and adds it to material and labor to get Make Cost / Unit. Power, consumables and tooling wear qualify. A share of the building, the ERP licence or the plant manager's salary does not.

Why not just compare purchase price with make cost per unit?

Because the two per-unit figures leave out the parts that decide it. Setup / Tooling Cost sits outside Make Cost / Unit and is recovered only across volume, while Buy Cost / Unit adds shipping and inspection to the quoted price. At low volume tooling dominates, which is exactly what break-even volume measures.

What if make and buy land within a few percent?

Treat it as a tie. A gap narrower than the accuracy of your own overhead rate is not a real gap, so decide on the things the numbers do not hold: capacity you free up, lead time, who owns the tooling, control over quality, and whether the part is yours to protect.

What should I do when the supplier comes out cheaper?

Check it against the volumes you might actually run before you move the work. The answer flips at the break-even volume, so a part you expect to grow can be worth making now. Then confirm the saving is bankable, since labor you do not remove and overhead you still absorb never show up in the accounts.

[Make Better Decisions]

Track Real Production Costs Across Every Job.

WorkCell captures material, labor, and overhead costs in real time so your make vs buy decisions are based on actual data, not estimates.